I was recently provoked by a good friend who happens to be a liberal democrat suggesting we all need to sacrifice to get our country back. I thought I would share with you my response.
“Sacrifice is an interesting word. Since almost 50% of the folks don’t pay anything in terms of income taxes and about 10% of us pay almost 90% who are you suggesting needs to sacrifice? If we took a 100% of all income of the folks earning over $1 million it would amount to about $2 Trillion. How does that eliminate our deficit? Having everyone pay a flat tax of 15% on income above $50,000 with no deductions is a solution that is fair but progressives find it “regressive” and their idea is tax the rich. Then everyone sacrifices (except those on the dole or who earn under $50k) but that is politically unacceptable.
Farmers and some big businesses enjoy welfare programs and we think that is ok since we get reliable food sources and cheaper products to buy, but it contributes to our problem. Eliminating them is the right thing to do but it will raise prices so we all will sacrifice. Resistance is already forming to those suggestions.
Things like right to life, dignified death and commitments kept (e.g. divorce rates) all contribute to a fabric of our society. All of these “values” have changed in the last 60 years. The pride we placed in working and saving to meet our future needs as individuals has been replaced with an expectation that the government will give us a pay check and pay our medical bills forever. The notion to work and make ends meet has been replaced by programs to educate folks how who to game the system and have babies to get welfare checks and free medical. You get the picture.
Our Constitution is the “social compact” which has allowed us to be the great country we were recognized to be. It allows for guarantied “access” to a good life. It does not provide for the government through “entitlements” to insure a good life – free medical for all, a government job for all, a pay check when you don’t work, a free education etc.
The Constitution isn’t a “living document” as Obama has suggested; it does allow for it to be changed but not easily. When it is to be changed it requires the States to vote on the Amendments. The progressives, however, have decided to avoid that method using signing statements by the Presidents (both Dem and Republicans) to routinely ignore laws that are passed. We say we are a country “ruled by law” but many find it “ok” to accept folks entering and living here illegally. We say we abide by The Constitution yet liberal judges and even some conservative ones shape their opinions to “make law” which is not in concert with the Constitution (our social compact) i.e. see “The Dirty Dozen” by Levy about how The Supreme court has eroded our liberty and violated the Constitution through their opinions dating back to 1933.
So to me sacrifice means accepting that the government isn’t going to be there to solve all my problems and that I have to work to get myself out of a hole. Sacrifice means I may have to accept a less clean environment for a time to allow the engine of our economy to function. Sacrifice means I might have to give up my life for my family and country in defense of them from enemies foreign or domestic.
Sacrifice DOES NOT mean that I will give up my liberty and rights to a government who will decide who my doctor can be, what light bulb I use or whether or not I use salt. It does not mean that I accept folks entering my country to take my money through welfare programs given to nurture votes.
So yes we all need to sacrifice but the biggest sacrifice is to not expect someone else to fix our problems and to inconvenience ourselves by getting involved in the movement to turn back “The Nanny State” movement of the progressives. You probably don’t agree but none the less I needed to respond. So I will sacrifice if you do too.”
P.S. please recognize that I did not say all Democrats are progressive nor are all Republicans conservative (some have proven to be just as “progressive”). Progressives believe in something called “Social Justice” which suggests that equality isn’t about opportunity but it is about everyone having an equal standing (no rich- no poor). This is something I will never accept as being either natural or worthy of pursuit. Justice means being fair and allowing equal opportunity to work hard and find our own way; it means each of us with our own means helping one another and not expecting the government to do it. I doesn’t mean taking private property from one to give to another against our will.
P.S. please recognize that I did not say all Democrats are progressive nor are all Republicans conservative (some have proven to be just as “progressive”). Progressives believe in something called “Social Justice” which suggests that equality isn’t about opportunity but it is about everyone having an equal standing (no rich- no poor). This is something I will never accept as being either natural or worthy of pursuit. Justice means being fair and allowing equal opportunity to work hard and find our own way; it means each of us with our own means helping one another and not expecting the government to do it. I doesn’t mean taking private property form one to give to another against our will.
Some have argued that CEOs and others “make too much” and they should be limited. Who is to say what is too much. I for one applaud anyone making as much as they can, assuming it is as a result of creating economic value. Several have even petitioned Goldman Sachs saying their execs made too much. This is a zero sum game, whatever they make gets returned to the system either through charitable donations, taxes paid or spending on “things”. People are employed and value is distributed. When someone sets themselves outside of the system to “judge” what is a fair compensation that can be paid we are is all going to loose. Free markets equalize everything –it may not be pretty but it is effective and fair in the long run. Have a nice day